In partnership with

Table of Contents

1. Opening Salvo

2. Did You See This?

3. Talent Management 101 (TM101)

4. The Plug

Opening Salvo

Performance Improvement Plans aren’t broken, they’re misused. Of all the well-intentioned interventions that have been weaponized against teams, this one is wielded the most, but that’s just my opinion.

They’re supposed to help employees course-correct with structure, clarity, and support. Instead, they’re often deployed as a paper trail for offboarding, dressed up in HR language no one believes.

That’s the problem. When employees hear “PIP,” most assume the decision is already made and in many orgs, they’re right.

Here’s what needs to change:
If your PIP process is more about documentation than development, it’s not a tool, it’s a signal that your performance management system is reactive, not strategic. And the impact is bigger than one employee. Misusing PIPs reinforces fear-based leadership and damages trust far beyond the individual on the plan.

Practical Personas (with a tinge of hyperbole)

• The Avoider Manager: They’ve been dodging performance conversations for months. The PIP is their first formal feedback and the employee is blindsided.

• The Checkbox Leader: They follow HR’s template but treat the plan like a countdown. They’re not hoping for improvement, they’re waiting for compliance.

• The Development-Oriented Leader: They give early feedback, set expectations clearly, and use PIPs as one part of a larger coaching strategy, not a standalone event.

Here’s What to Consider:

• Has the employee had clear, documented feedback before the PIP?

• Is the plan focused on measurable behaviors and outcomes, not vague traits like “attitude”?

• Are there checkpoints and support mechanisms built into the process?

If the answer to any of these is no, it’s not a performance improvement plan. It’s a formality pretending to be support.

Did You See This?

Email marketing that actually performs

Unlock the strategies that drive $36 in return for every $1 spent.

Learn how to build quality email lists people actually want to join, craft messages that outperform industry benchmarks, implement advanced segmentation that drives conversions, and measure metrics that prove real business impact—all in clear, actionable steps.

Get the full guide—free when you subscribe to the Masters in Marketing newsletter.

Join marketing pros who rely on Masters in Marketing for expert insights delivered straight to their inbox, twice a week.

Download now for free here.

Talent Management 101 (TM101)

The Plug

This newsletter is brought to you by AstutEdge, a consultancy dedicated to developing and deploying a people-first talent management culture. We solve both obvious and hidden challenges by optimizing performance, engagement, and development across the entire HR, People, and Talent spectrum.

How We Help:

• Optimize Team Performance: Implementing tailored strategies that improve efficiency, engagement, and collaboration.

• Develop Leadership: Nurture leaders who inspire and drive organizational success through targeted development.

• Enhance Employee Experience: Boosting morale and retention with data-driven engagement programs.

• Improve Organizational Culture: Providing insights and solutions to create a positive, high-performing work environment.

• Increase Business Growth: Aligning talent management practices with business goals to drive innovation and growth.

• Strengthen Collaboration: Facilitating team cohesion through CliftonStrengths-based coaching and development.

This plug is shameless and should be shared widely. If your organization or a partner organization could benefit from talent management support, we’d love to help!

Unbiased Business Insights, Every Week

Get a weekly knowledge digest of business insights from 1440’s Business & Finance newsletter. Expect concise rundowns, context-rich visuals, and curated links to keep you ahead of the finance curve. Join 1440 for crisp explanations of business trends —no MBA required.

Sign Up Here